2015 GCGC
CONFERENCE: Stanford

5-6 June 2015

Why Do Corporate Charters Waive Liability for Breach of the Duty of Care?

Speaker:

Holger Spamann

Professor of Law

Discussant:

Curtis Milhaupt

Parker Professor of Comparative Corporate Law and Fuyo Professor of Japanese Law; Director

Abstract:

This paper clarifies why corporate governance arrangements in public firms generally do not make use of judicial evaluations of boards’ and managers’ business decisions. In principle, information generated in litigation, particularly discovery, could usefully supplement public information (particulary stock prices) in the provision of performance incentives. In particular, the optimally adjusted combination of standard performance pay and litigation could impose less risk on boards and managers than standard performance pay alone. Caps, indemnification, or insurance could achieve the requisite tailoring of litigation payments; ruinous liability risk and ensuing risk aversion would not be an issue. Similarly, court biases can be offset by contractual adjustments. The appendix shows this in a formal model summarizing well-known results.

Consequently, the reason not to use litigation incentives is not absolute but a simple cost-benefit trade-off. Litigation is expensive, while the benefits from additional information are limited. Stock prices already provide fairly good information, courts have difficulties evaluating business decisions and thus provide only noisy information, and the agency conflict in standard business decisions is limited. A different result may obtain, however, when other governance mechanisms are weaker, particulary when stock prices or other reliable public signals are not available; when courts can measure the decision against an accepted benchmark; or as the agency conflict becomes more severe.


Visit our partner site :footer-logo-new

CONTACT US

We're not around right now. But you can send us an email and we'll get back to you, asap.

Sending
Designed By Astwood

Log in with your credentials

Forgot your details?

peuterey hamburg peuterey regina woolrich kinderjacke duvetica adhara duvetica damen duvetica daunenmantel duvetica herren duvetica kinder duvetica kinderjacke duvetica mantel duvetica deutschland barbour lille barbour moto barbour paris barbour pas cher barbour shop online doudoune moncler aliexpress parajumper fille parajumper rouge parajumpers wikipedia pjs beige pjs occasion pjs paris peuterey femme peuterey homme